Family Farm Alliance Op-Ed by President Patrick O’Toole – CSU’s Water in the West Symposium
This week Colorado State University hosts the symposium, “Water in the West,” to discuss water policy and community, environment, and industry issues for Colorado and the entire West. The program includes a variety of Colorado politicians, policy makers and other business leaders, as well as the previous and current U.S. Secretaries of Agriculture.
Unfortunately, the conference agenda fails to include voices from the farming and rural communities of Colorado, a critical component of Western water use, even though it promises discussion of creative solutions addressing the needs of food producers.
I am a rancher and irrigator on the Colorado/Wyoming border, and the President of the Family Farm Alliance, representing irrigators in the 17 Western states. The Alliance’s mission is “to ensure the availability of reliable, affordable irrigation water supplies to Western farmers and ranchers.” The Alliance’s Board of Directors is made up of farmers and ranchers. Our Advisory Board includes water managers, attorneys and other water professionals. We are credible problem solvers, as evidenced by 70 invitations to testify before Congressional water and natural resources committees since 2005.
We can get to the ditch level anywhere in the West and produce solutions for many of the complicated conflicts in the water world.
Unfortunately, organizers of this week’s symposium in Denver apparently chose to disregard the state’s agricultural community perspective, despite the strong presence of cabinet-level secretaries. We are concerned that some may simply view Western farms and ranches as reservoirs of water to support further urban growth along the I-25 corridor. Is this vision of even more urban sprawl shared by all Coloradans? I know many of my rural neighbors eschew that scenario, especially if irrigation water for rural farms, ranches and the communities that serve them is being viewed as the source to fuel that growth.
On our ranch today, we are preparing ditches and sprinklers for an early and short irrigation season. Sandhill cranes, blue herons, golden and bald eagles crisscross our watershed, which is a tributary to the Colorado River. Our valley has one of the most impressive trout passage programs in the U.S. The agricultural families who live in this community have a new generation of young farmers and ranchers on the ground. We raise “cattle, sheep, horses, dogs and children” …and sometimes, expectations.
But it can all go away—the food production, the wildlife habitat, the rural economy – especially if the continued pressures of urban growth look to farms for their future water supplies.
Much is being made of the current Colorado “system conservation” pilot program. This program – if implemented correctly – could assist the Colorado Basin in drier years. However, we must ensure that it does not instead become a program that simply pays farmers and ranchers to not irrigate, and by default become an annual “buy and dry” program for the Western Slope. Demand management (water conservation), water recycling, watershed management, conveyance, desalination, water transfers, groundwater storage, regulatory reform and surface storage are all needed in a diversified management portfolio. Importantly, surface storage provides a degree of operational flexibility and significant water supply volumes that cannot be provided by other management actions.
Western farmers like our Alliance’s members have developed some of the most efficient water use methods in the history of the world. However, one size doesn’t fit all. For example, flood irrigation during spring and early summer can mimic historic floodplain function, providing groundwater recharge and critical habitat diversity, particularly for waterfowl and other migratory birds.
Ranches and farms produce food, crucial to the rural and national economies. The role of efficiency is important, but balanced, locally-tailored water management is more important for healthy functioning systems benefitting food production and the environment.
The role of production agriculture is the crucial vector in a discussion that will indicate the Colorado we want or the Colorado we deserve. Including farmers and ranchers in broader policy discussions like the CSU symposium only makes common sense.
Op-Ed written by Family Farm Alliance President Patrick O’Toole
Patrick O’Toole, a member of the Family Farm Alliance’s Board of Directors since 1998 and a former member of Wyoming’s House of Representatives, was named as the organization’s fifth President in March 2005. O’Toole is a cattle and sheep rancher and hay grower with strong backgrounds in irrigated agriculture and Wyoming politics. He and his family live near Savery, Wyoming. Mr. O’Toole and his wife, Sharon, live on a ranch that has been in her family since 1881. It straddles the Wyoming-Colorado border and has long afforded Mr. O’Toole the opportunity to view some unique water issues, first hand. He served in Wyoming’s 64-member House from 1986-92. His assignments included a Select Water Committee and the Agriculture and Water committees. He and others in his region struggled for years to get a scaled-down storage project, Upper Savery Reservoir, developed. The lake is now delivering water. Pat O’Toole’s interest in water intersected with the Family Farm Alliance while he was serving on the Clinton administration’s Western Water Policy Review Advisory Commission. Mr. O’Toole was the only commissioner representing Western irrigated agriculture and, in the end, refused to sign the report, opting instead to prepare a dissenting alternative report. Mr. O’Toole is presently serving on the Advisory Committee for AGree, a national agricultural policy group. The O’Toole family and Ladder Ranch were the recipients of the distinguished 2014 Wyoming Leopold Environmental Stewardship Award. Water is listed as a top priority in the discussion. Pat and Sharon met while students at Colorado State University (where Pat graduated with a degree in philosophy). They have three children, including a daughter and son, and six grandchildren living on the ranch. Another daughter lives in Denver with her husband
We strive to do it all here at Family Farm Alliance. Our Non-Profit Organization provides a dynamic work environment where deadlines are met and goals are not only met, but they are exceeded. We work on many exciting initiatives to improve the lives of others, and are very proud of the work we do. Learn about our exciting initiatives, and what we are working on every day in order to promote change.