05-05-16 CSU Department of Animal Sciences: Dr Temple Grandin “Setting the record straight”…

CSU Dept of Animal SciencelogoSetting the record straight

Dr Temple GrandinTemple Grandin

The Wonkblog article “Why a top animal science expert is worried about the milk industry” by Roberto Ferdman has caused considerable discussion among the dairy industry and academia. My purpose in this writing is to clarify what was said and what are my opinions of the dairy industry.

The premise of Mr. Ferdman’s 15-minute phone interview with me was to help explain the graphs showing the decrease in number of dairy cows and the increase in production per cow. During the interview I praised the excellent Colorado dairies I visited with Bill Wailes prior to his death. I also indicated that, in my opinion, excellent dairies like these represent a third of the dairies in the United States. This was interpreted by Mr. Ferdman to mean that two thirds of the dairies in the United States are bad. This is not true.

I have and will always be an advocate for animal wellbeing. However, I do believe we need to be concerned about pushing biology too far without the proper support for extremes in production. After learning that high producing cows, such as Gigi, have good longevity, I will stop making statements that relate production to longevity. Recent information from semen distributors has also shown that concentrated selection for size and production has been replaced by selection for health and longevity. It is great to have genetic options to improve traits and wellbeing. In addition, I just learned that recently published and soon-to-be published scientific studies show great improvement in lameness issues previously associated with high producing cows.

There are always areas where improvement is needed. Too many cows that should be euthanized on the farm are still arriving at packing plants. Another problem I have observed is very tall cows and some tall dairy steers are bruising their backs in transit. Truck size is limited to 13 feet 6 inches due to bridge clearance. If cattle are too tall, they may require single deck trailers.

In conclusion, I will be clearer when talking to the public. The majority of the dairy industry is doing a great job with animal wellbeing through improved facilities, workforce management, feeding and selection, but there are still a few who really hurt all of animal agriculture when poor decisions are made.  While I praise the majority, we all need to work together to improve the others.  If there are ever questions or concerns, please reach out to me at 970-229-0703.

3 thoughts on “05-05-16 CSU Department of Animal Sciences: Dr Temple Grandin “Setting the record straight”…

  1. Thank you Dr Grandin for clearing this up and confirming that the most dairy farmers are doing an excellent job. Advances in environment, nutrition, health and management are the key to removing stress from animals and allowing them to fully achieve their genetic potential. Healthy cows make the most milk.


  2. Thank you for clarifying this report. I had faith that my respect for your work could continue. The media tends to editorialize interviews. I knew you would research the facts and continue to support the dairy industries work on making sure animals had the best care possible. Thank you for all you do in regard to animal welfare and autism awareness.


  3. One more example Temple of you running your mouth as an expert without “facts” or “science” to back it up. Your pattern of such examples is mounting faster than your peer reviewed work. Please consider the impact of such emotional outburst as you are actually gainfully employed at a Land Grant University which is based on scientific progress. We produce more with less because of such great institutions.


Comments are closed.